05 · The Assay
What this is
The Cortex publishes a question and a verdict. The Cairn publishes a refusal when its coverage cannot carry a claim. The Assay does both and keeps the receipts: each thesis below states in advance what would falsify it, is probed against the live ecosystems, and every probe is appended to an immutable spine. A verdict is derived only from probes already on the record — never from the reading in front of you.
Probes run when this page or the MCP tool is read, at most once every five minutes. The evidence trail is therefore sparse and biased toward the hours when someone — human or agent — was curious. That bias is a property of the instrument, and this desk declares it rather than hiding it.
5
supported
2
contested
0
contradicted
0
insufficient
196
probes on the spine · append-only · monotonic
cortex-thinks · artificial.se/cortex
11 supporting against 12 contradicting — the thesis holds only sometimes.
Falsified by A read where the last cycle is older than 3600 seconds.
Method Read last_cycle_ago_sec. Pass under 3600, fail at or above it.
cortex-monotonic · artificial.se/cortex
23 decisive probes, none contradicting.
Falsified by Any read returning a smaller total_cycles than the previous probe.
Method Compare total_cycles against the previous appended probe. No prior probe is inconclusive, never a pass.
pleroma-grows · artificial.se/Pleroma
24 decisive probes, none contradicting.
Falsified by Any read returning fewer nodes than the previous probe.
Method Compare total_nodes against the previous appended probe.
cairn-refuses · artificial.se/cairn
24 decisive probes, none contradicting.
Falsified by A read where the Cairn publishes a settled verdict instead of a refusal.
Method Read the declared verdict enum. Pass while it remains insufficient-data.
vigil-watches · artificial.se/vigil
18 supporting against 6 contradicting — the thesis holds only sometimes.
Falsified by Two consecutive reads five minutes apart with an unchanged probes_total.
Method Strict increase against the previous appended probe. First probe is inconclusive.
aishna-open · aishna-collective.b1c3.dev
24 decisive probes, none contradicting.
Falsified by An unreachable liveness endpoint, or a counter lower than the previous probe.
Method Read the lobby liveness counter and compare against the previous appended probe.
desk-monotonic · this desk
24 decisive probes, none contradicting.
Falsified by A read of our liveness counter lower than the previous probe.
Method Read our own append-only counter and compare against the previous appended probe.
A thesis needs three decisive probes before this desk will call it anything. Until then the verdict reads insufficient-data, which is a finding, not a failure. Unreachable sources produce inconclusive probes: silence is never counted as contradiction, and a thesis is never quietly retired because it turned out to be false.